UPSC Civil Services · 2025 · Prelims GS Paper I · Q81 · Past-year questions with answers

PrepKar by Manisri Technologies Private Limited

Union Executive · 2025 · Prelims GS Paper I · Q81

Listen to the explanation · English–Hindi

Audio may not play outside India.

Audio transcript

Ordinance कानून बनाने का एक साधन है, जिसकी conditions Constitution तय करता है। Article one hundred and twenty-three concerns the President's power. इसे केवल executive instruction समझना सही नहीं होगा। An Ordinance has the force and effect of an Act of Parliament, but that statement operates within constitutional limits. कानून जैसा effect होने का अर्थ Constitution से ऊपर होना नहीं है; power का source और उसकी सीमा साथ पढ़िए।

An Ordinance can amend ordinary Central legislation within the competent field. It cannot use that route to override Fundamental Rights. दोनों propositions में फर्क पहचानिए। किसी statute को बदलना और Constitution को बदलना एक जैसा काम नहीं है। किसी Central Act को amend करने की क्षमता से constitutional protection हटाने की क्षमता अपने आप नहीं निकलती। The word any in a broad exam statement must be read within the lawmaker's constitutional competence.

Retrospective operation means the law is given effect from an earlier date. Such operation is possible, while constitutional limits still apply. यहाँ can और always valid के बीच फर्क बचाकर रखिए। A recorded retrospective Ordinance does not mean every retrospective provision will survive challenge. उदाहरण से possibility समझिए, universal approval मत निकालिए। यहाँ सवाल power की सम्भावना का है; इससे उसके हर सम्भव इस्तेमाल के valid होने की guarantee नहीं निकलती।

Ordinance को parliamentary control और उसकी तय समय-सीमा के साथ भी समझना होता है। It must be laid before both Houses of Parliament and ceases to operate six weeks after Parliament reassembles, or earlier if both Houses pass resolutions disapproving it or the President withdraws it. इस time rule को date of promulgation से सीधा six weeks मत गिनिए। The constitutional reference point matters. जब कोई अवधि सुनाई दे तो उसकी शुरुआत कहाँ से है, यह साथ लिखिए; number याद होना अकेले पर्याप्त नहीं होगा।

As of the twenty twenty-five exam: The accepted answer is option c, statements one and three only: amendment of ordinary Central legislation and possible retrospective operation. The claim that an Ordinance can abridge a Fundamental Right is rejected. all three claims की अलग सीमा देखिए। Keep the categories separate: avoid treating the Act-like force of an Ordinance as freedom from constitutional review. ऐसा विस्तार मुख्य rule से नहीं निकलता। Keep ordinary legislation, constitutional rights and commencement date in separate boxes before judging the combination.

Trivia time: which Article concerns the Governor's Ordinance-making power? President वाले provision से अलग number पहचानिए। The answer is Article two hundred and thirteen. For further reading, compare the issuing authority, conditions and legislative control for the two powers. केवल Ordinance शब्द समान होने से दोनों authorities की पूरी constitutional position एक जैसी मत मानिए। A careful comparison begins with the actual Article and the legislature involved.

Skip to options
PYQ · UPSC Civil Services 2025 · Prelims GS Paper I · Q81 Difficulty 3/5

Union Executive› President & Vice-President

With reference to the Indian polity, consider the following statements :

  1. I. An Ordinance can amend any Central Act.
  2. II. An Ordinance can abridge a Fundamental Right.
  3. III. An Ordinance can come into effect from a back date

Which of the statements given above are correct?

Answer c.

Explanation Answer · c

Option (c) — statements I and III are correct. An Ordinance has the same force as an Act, so it can amend a Central law and can be given retrospective effect; but it cannot abridge a Fundamental Right, because an Ordinance is 'law' under Article 13. Article 123 says an Ordinance promulgated by the President 'shall have the same force and effect as an Act of Parliament', so its power is co-extensive with Parliament's legislative power — it can amend or repeal a Central Act, subject to the same limits. Because Article 13(3)(a) defines 'law' to include an ordinance, Article 13(2) bars an Ordinance from taking away or abridging Fundamental Rights, exactly as it bars a statute. Retrospective operation is an ordinary incident of legislative power, so an Ordinance may be given effect from a back date; the only firm bar is Article 20(1), which forbids retrospective criminal liability or enhanced penalties. Krishna Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar (2017) confirmed that ordinance-making is subject to judicial review and that laying the Ordinance before the legislature is mandatory.

Prepared with PrepKar AI and checked; it may contain errors.

Free while the offer lasts